Monday, September 13, 2010

The Woman on the Beach (1947)

Jean Renoir’s American masterpiece, Woman on the Beach (1947) is easily the best Hollywood film by the resolutely humanist director of such classic films as Rules of the Game (1939) and Boudu Saved From Drowning (1932). When Renoir fled France with the advent of the Nazi onslaught, he initially landed at 20th Century Fox, where he directed the torrid melodrama Swamp Water (1941), shot on location in Georgia. The film failed to click at the box office, and Renoir left Fox for Universal, where he began work on a Deanna Durbin musical, but walked off the film after a few weeks, upset with Universal’s factory production methods. The film was eventually released as The Amazing Mrs. Holiday (1943), with writer/producer Bruce Manning taking sole directorial credit. Leaving Universal, Renoir landed at RKO, where he was able to direct the noirish French resistance drama This Land Is Mine (1943), starring Charles Laughton as a meek schoolmaster, through the film was marred by a stage bound, Hollywood “studio” look, in contrast to Renoir’s best, more naturalistic films.

Renoir then left RKO, and made a brief propaganda short, Salute to France (1944), before creating The Southerner (1945) and The Diary of a Chambermaid (1946), both independent productions with modest budgets and shooting schedules. Renoir’s American odyssey was coming to an end when he returned to RKO for his last Hollywood film, the brutally vicious Woman on the Beach, which effectively ended Renoir’s ties with the American film industry.

Joan Bennett, then at the height of her box-office fame after her memorable role as the duplicitous prostitute Kitty Marsh in Fritz Lang’s Scarlet Street, heard of Renoir’s interest in making a film for RKO, and insisted that Renoir direct her new project, then titled Desirable Woman. However, as the film was being readied for production, RKO’s production chief, the gifted Charles Koerner, died on February 2, 1946 of leukemia 1, and Jack Gross took over as producer, much to Renoir’s chagrin. Koerner, said Renoir, was “. . . an understanding man, a man who knew the film market, who understood the workings of it very well, but who allowed for experimentation just the same” 1. Gross was much less given to individual nuance in his films as producer, but nevertheless Renoir found that with Joan Bennett as his star, he could afford a relatively luxurious production schedule.

Still, the scenario and production of Woman on the Beach bothered Renoir, if only because it was unlike any other film he had ever attempted. As he noted at the time, “I wanted to try and tell a love story based purely on physical attraction, a story in which emotions played no part . . . In all my previous films I had tied to depict the bonds uniting the individual to his background . . . I had proclaimed the consoling truth that the world is one; and now I was embarked on a study of persons whose sole idea was to close the door on the absolutely concrete phenomenon which we call life” 1. This, of course, is the very essence of noir, and whatever his misgivings, Renoir embraced this new emotional terrain with his customary skill and insight.

Woman on the Beach tells the tale of Tod Butler (Charles Bickford), an extremely successful American artist, whose career has been cut short by an accident, in which he was deprived of his eyesight. His wife, Peggy (Joan Bennett), loves and hates Tod in equal measure, but remains bound to him, because it was she who blinded Tod during a lover’s quarrel. The two live in a seaside cottage near a U.S. Coast Guard base, in a state of perpetual disharmony; Tod keeps his paintings locked up in a closet as his only link to the past, while Peggy wants to sell the paintings and move to New York, seeking the fast life the two once shared when Tod could see. Into this uneasy marriage comes Lieutenant Scott Burnett (Robert Ryan), a young officer who has recently survived a torpedo attack, and is now recovering from his physical wounds, but is still mentally unbalanced. Peggy immediately seduces Scott, much to the displeasure of Scott’s fiancé, Eve Geddes (Nan Leslie).

Scott becomes obsessed with “freeing” Peggy from Tod, whom he believes is not really blind, but rather manipulating Peggy so that she will stay with him out of guilt. Scott creates a series of cruel tests for Tod, in one instance standing by while Tod walks off a cliff, in an attempt to prove his theory. Convinced at last that Tod really is blind, but unable to free himself from Peggy’s grip, Tod and Scott battle for Peggy’s affections, culminating in an astounding final scene, in which Tod sets his house and paintings on fire, in a desperate attempt to free himself of his past life. As the house explodes in flames, Tod renounces his past ways, and tells Peggy to go with Scott. But Peggy chooses to stay with Tod, who now intends to pursue a career as a writer; Scott returns to Eve, and domestic tranquility.

While the shooting of the film went smoothly, the release of Woman on the Beach was fraught with difficulties. The film was given a “sneak preview” in Santa Barbara before a crowd of young students who greeted the film with derisive catcalls, and Renoir was forced by RKO to recut the film. Scenes with Joan Bennett were reshot, and the love scenes with Ryan and Bennett were also revised (Bergan 262)1. The final result pleased no one, and the film was released in May of 1947 to “general public indifference” 1. Renoir, sensing that the political landscape in the United States was about to change for the worse, with the House Un-American Activities Committee hearings on the horizon, left Hollywood shortly thereafter; his next project would be The River (1951), a Technicolor feature shot entirely on location in India. From The River, Renoir returned to postwar France, making the gently elegiac French Cancan (1955) and other films before his final retirement from the director’s chair. Summing up his Hollywood period, Renoir commented that “Although I don’t regret my American films, I know for a fact they don’t even come close to any ideal I have for my work . . . they represent seven years of unrealized works and unrealized hopes. And seven years of deceptions too . . .” 1.

But even if this is so, Woman on the Beach is still a remarkable film, the only true noir that Renoir ever made, and one of the most economical and relentless examinations of a marriage in collapse ever filmed, along with Jean-Luc Godard’s 1963 masterpiece Le Mépris (Contempt). As Tod Butler, Bickford gives the most nuanced performance of his career, at once tender and yet dangerous, while Robert Ryan brings an intensity to the role of Scott Burnett that is both haunting and achingly realistic. Joan Bennett’s foredoomed femme fatale is essentially a reprise of her role in Scarlet Street, but in Woman on the Beach, she seems more tragic and human than in Lang’s much colder moral universe. At 71 minutes, the film has little time to waste, and is harrowingly compact. Woman on the Beach is Renoir’s one true American masterpiece, unto which he distilled all his disdain for the Hollywood studio system and American culture.


Written by Wheeler Winston Dixon

About the Author: Wheeler Winston Dixon is the James Ryan Endowed Professor of Film Studies, Professor of English at the University of Nebraska, Lincoln, Coordinator of the Film Studies Program at UNL, and with Gwendolyn Audrey Foster, Editor-in-Chief of the Quarterly Review of Film and Video. His newest books include A History of Horror (Rutgers University Press, 2010), Film Noir and the Cinema of Paranoia (Rutgers University Press and Edinburgh University Press, 2009), and A Short History of Film, written with Gwendolyn Audrey Foster (Rutgers University Press and I.B. Tauris, 2008). As a filmmaker, his complete works are in the permanent collection of The Museum of Modern Art, following a career retrospective at MoMA in 2003.

1 Bergan, Ronald. Jean Renoir: Projections of Paradise. New York: Overlook Press, 1995.


  1. Renoir made La Chienne and La Nuit de Carrefour in France in the early 30s - two classic noirs.

    Despite his problems in Hollywood, Renoir was very respectful of b-movies. In a 1954 interview, Renoir said:

    “I’ll say a few words about Val Lewton, because he was an extremely interesting person; unfortunately he died, it’s already been a few years. He was one of the first, maybe the first, who had the idea to make films that weren’t expensive, with ‘B’ picture budgets, but with certain ambitions, with quality screenplays, telling more refined stories than usual. Don’t go thinking that I despise “B” pictures; in general I like them better than big, pretentious psychological films they’re much more fun. When I happen to go to the movies in America, I go see “B” pictures. First of all, they are an expression of the great technical quality of Hollywood. Because, to make a good western in a week, the way they do at Monogram, starting Monday and finishing Saturday, believe me, that requires extraordinary technical ability; and detective stories are done with the same speed. I also think that “B” pictures are often better than important films because they are made so fast that the filmmaker obviously has total freedom; they don’t have time to watch over him.”

  2. What a fantastic film. I really like Joan Bennett a lot. Blondes don't have all the fun!

  3. Turner Classics is playing it on Nov 11, 05:30PM


Comment above or join the discussion at the Back Alley Noir review section. All comments at Noir of the Week are shared at Back Alley