
Posted by Paulcito
Meet the Harpers of
Balboa, California. Meet Mrs. Lucia Harper (
Joan Bennett), All-American housewife, who hops into the family sedan in the film's first frames for a unexpected drive to Los Angeles. Before we've even met the rest of the Harper family "team", Lucia drives us straight into noirsville, to a seedy L.A. cocktail joint-cum-gambling hall. She is geared for a confrontation with her daughter Bea's pimpish older boyfriend, "ex-art dealer" (and really, is there anything worse than being an EX-art dealer?) Ted Darby. Darby bemusedly admits to mother, almost apologetically, that he needs money. Just a little handout, that's all, and he'll disappear from the scene.
Here, it seems, we have another family noir in the Lynchian mode, where all is not well in suburbia and bad things will happen in Balboa. Or so we hope. But as the de rigueur noir voice-over fades away, to never return, in the first moments of Lucia's trip, so too should your expectations that this will be another potboiler by the book. Director
Max Ophüls makes this film interesting by going through the noir melodrama motions only to swerve away, for better AND worse, from the expected action, and take a dig at the American Dream. The movie tempts us down certain well-trod noir roads only to defy the cliché each time in little ways.
Its Christmas-time and daughter Bea, played by
Geraldine Brooks (best known in noir circles for her role in
Possessed), is that middle-class species of girl who has opted for art school instead of college; Darby is her art school discovery, but she insists to Mom it's no "nasty love affair". Returning from L.A., Lucia discovers the whole family is curious about her mysterious drive and she confronts Bea about Darby. Bea, who is crushing hard, will have none of it. Mr. Harper is nowhere to be seen, a traveling architect relegated in this film to a telephonic presence who is no more than a few phone calls. This film is all Joan Bennett's. Son David (
David Bair) is a gee-whiz teenager, only interested in car engines and little post modern ironies, at one point he exclaims, "I'm a growing boy, I need my rest!" The household is completed by live-in maid and confidante Sybil (an uncredited
Frances E. Williams) and Lucia's retiree father, the elder Mr. Harper.

You might think at this point that we are entering
Mildred Pierce territory, where Mom will struggle frantically to avoid her daughter's downfall at Darby's hands, but Ophüls has other plans. During a boathouse assignation with Teddy that same night, Bea hears Darby admit that Mom was right, he does want moolah, and how. Darby, an interesting
Shepperd Strudwick, is a rakish cad, tall and yet somehow not physically menacing. Strudwick's other noir credentials included
Beyond A Reasonable Doubt,
Chicago Deadline,
Strange Triangle, and
All The King's Men, though he was better known as a television character actor.
But he has sorely underestimated teenybopper Bea, who, in a fit of anger, slaps him good (twice!) and then is further inspired to brain him with her flashlight. Poor Darby. He staggers after her, hoping romantically to explain they both can use the cash, when the concussion overcomes him and he topples off the pier and onto a submerged anchor. He's all washed up. The next morning that is, when Mrs. Bennett, awake at dawn and too nervous to sleep, discovers his body neatly tangled under their pier.
One supposes the dispatching of Ted Darby is the titular Reckless Moment, but perhaps that honor belongs to Lucia Harper: like any good noir hausfrau, she decides to drag the corpse out to the power boat and goes looking for swampy new digs for Darby's remains while the town church bells chime ominously in the distance.
And here comes Ophüls curve ball number two: after Lucia anchors Darby but good in the murky deep - doesn't every planned community in California have a convenient swamp across the highway? -- we expect a police procedural: the police are trolling the local waters and the town is abuzz with the murder (Darby's body washes up of course, anchor notwithstanding). Look for a young
William Schallert as the police lieutenant. But this film is interested less in solving the crime than in tracking Joan Bennett's reaction to it all. Ophüls has a masterful way of letting the melodrama speak for itself, and Bennett's nervous reactions to each setback are naturally acted. Bennett has none of the moll-ishness on display here that made her a
femme fatale in
Scarlet Street or
Woman in the Window. All of Bennett's really tormented scenes are played straight, as she sobs on her bed, smokes like mad, or makes surreptitious phone calls at the local pharmacy booth. The use of moody noir music is judicious and cinematographer
Burnett Guffey keeps Balboa shadowy and windy, showing the adept hand that won him an
Academy Award for
From Here to Eternity. Pace and emotion are provided by Ophüls trademark long takes and tracking shots. All this combines to give the film an understated, steady realism and nervous air which helps bring home the always comforting noir message that, even in suburbia, you are only a well-placed anchor tip away from homicide.

One reviewer described this style as a "deliberate tossing away of obvious opportunities for suspense and emotional climaxes" - but Ophüls is more interested in subtly indicting middle-class America's fatuousness than grinding out a crime suspenser. As always, his preferred theme is entrapment, both social and romantic. Ophüls at the time was best known for 1948's
Letter From an Unknown Woman with
Joan Fontaine and
Louis Jourdan, and it was his European sensibility that Columbia wanted when they hired him. He had just made his other noir foray,
Caught, at MGM, also starring James Mason. Producer
Walter Wanger, who was married to Joan Bennett at the time, wanted her to star and then got both Mason and Ophüls. However, a noir melodrama released at Christmas wasn't what the public wanted, and Ophüls returned to France in the 50s to make such classics as
Earrings of Madame de...,
La Ronde, and
Lola Montès.
The Reckless Moment was his last film stateside.
The next twist comes in the form of Martin Donnolly (
James Mason), as the nicest sting-running Irishman you ever met. It seems Donnely and his silent menace of a partner -- the ominous Mr. Nagel -- have previously extorted daughter Bea's jailbait love letters from the hapless Darby. Donnolly shows up in Balboa to extort 5Gs out of Lucia in exchange for keeping the letters from the police and press. With her husband Tom out of town, Lucia has no choice but to give in to his demands, and brings him along on a desperate quest to raise the money that takes them from bank to loan office to pawn shop.

Mason's Irishman is a stoic piece of work - he seems from the very start to be making love to Joan rather than extorting her. He accompanies her shopping and even invites her to lunch, all the while drilling her laconically for the hush-hush money. But Ophüls doesn't lead us there either, there is no temptation that Lucia will cheat on Berlin-bound hubby Tom.
Mason sees her small town existence as "a prison", but she sets her teeth and never answers his overture. Her home life defines her, eternally preoccupied with her children's rolled-up sleeves and presence at breakfast and dinner. Donnoly's words are just spoken failure, his longing for the things he never had, or can have, because he always was "the bad one." Mason's role here is wonderfully nuanced and for me was quite different from his incursion in
Caught.
After an anxious weekend trying to get the money and safeguard Bea's innocence, Lucia can see Mason is head over heels for her. He even offers to get half the cash for Nagel himself and drops the threats when another of Darby's cronies is arrested on suspicion of murder. But nasty puppetmaster Nagel steps in, disgusted with Donnolly's weakness toward Mrs. Harper, and the film ends in a boathouse confrontation between the two men. Nagel, a forgettable
Roy Roberts, never exudes the full menace he should.
When Nagel finally gets it, Mason laments, "He was better than I was - he had no illusions about himself." In true noir fashion, the murderous thug is the ones with hopes and shattered dreams and Mom and daughter kill and cover it up. Without giving away the end, we find Donnolly sacrificing himself so the Harpers of Balboa can go back to their home life, the reckless moment forgotten in the glow of a blue Christmas tree and middle class security.
Reckless Moment, based on the short story The Blank Wall, by Elisabeth Sanxay Holding, was remade in 2001 as
The Deep End, a neo-noir retelling with
Tilda Swinton in Bennett's role. Reckless Moment is available on a crisply restored Columbia R2 DVD that was released in the UK in September 2006.
A reckless moment: